Skip to main content Scroll Top

How Do I Fundraise More Effectively? Start With What You’re Ready to Build

How Do I Fundraise More Effectively? Start With What You’re Ready to Build

When nonprofit executives ask me how to fundraise more effectively, they are usually already working hard. They are short staffed. They need more money to grow their mission. Their calendars are full of events, appeals, and donor meetings, yet the organization still doesn’t have the resources to get where it needs to go.

I often see the same pattern: they are focused on their current donors, asking for small amounts, and spending considerable time on transactional fundraising. Another sponsorship. Another ticket sale. Another event that takes months to organize.

My first question is: What are you building toward?

Before you can fundraise for growth, you have to do the work to define that growth, understand what it will cost, and prepare your organization to deliver.

Think beyond the organization you are today

At Turpentine Creek Wildlife Refuge, we worked with leaders who were still thinking of themselves as a small regional organization. Their approach depended heavily on getting people to visit. They believed people needed to tour the refuge to become engaged.

We helped them see themselves as a global organization. Their work had connections to education, conservation, museums, and tourism. Those connections opened opportunities to engage people and institutions beyond the animal welfare supporters they already knew.

The mission had more relevance than their fundraising approach reflected.

That is something I want every nonprofit executive to consider. You may be so close to your work that you see only one reason someone would support it. Your mission may connect to several priorities that matter deeply to other donors. 

Ask yourself: What are the pillars of our work that could attract investment beyond the one thing we always talk about? Then look further ahead. What is your big, hairy, audacious goal (your BHAG)? With the right investment, what could you change?

Give yourself room to answer that before shrinking the vision to fit this year’s fundraising results.

Build the plan behind the vision

A bigger vision carries responsibility. You have to know how you will execute it. This is where my Five Factors™ Framework comes in: Plan, Outcomes, Budget, Team, and Revenue. These factors need to work together so the organization is ready for the investment it seeks.

Start with a business plan and a budget that shows what it will actually cost to execute. What will you do? What people and resources will it take? What will it cost to deliver the results you are promising? That work gives you a fundraising goal grounded in your mission. It gives you a basis for a campaign. Too often, organizations set the goal by looking at last year’s revenue and adding a little more. That can keep you working within the same limits year after year.

Your plan should help you understand the resources required to accomplish something meaningful. Then you can build a revenue strategy around funding it.

Choose outcomes that matter

You also need two or three solid outcomes. I want to know more than how many people you sheltered. How many, two years later, are no longer homeless and have safe, stable housing?

I want to know more than how many meals you served. What would it take for a community to create and embrace a solution that ensures no child in its ZIP code goes without three meals a day?

The number of people served tells us something about activity and reach. The outcome tells us what changed. That distinction matters when you are asking someone to invest in your work. You need to be able to explain the change you are working toward and how you will know you are making progress.It matters for your decisions, too. If a program consumes time and money but doesn’t produce outcomes that matter, you need to take a hard look at it.

Being busy is expensive when your team is already stretched.

Make room for the work

I know what a short-staffed executive is thinking: When am I supposed to do all of this?

You have to make choices.

Some things can be delegated. Some activities need to end. Some programs may need to change because their outcomes don’t justify the resources they require. Those decisions are hard. An event may have a long history. A program may have passionate supporters. You may be accustomed to handling work that someone else could own. But if every hour goes to maintaining what already exists, where will the capacity to grow come from?

Ultimately, you have to decide whether you will continue operating at your current scale or do the work that makes growth possible. You cannot keep adding fundraising activity indefinitely to a team that is already at capacity.

Be ready for the gift

When I talk about raising more money, I am talking about doing the work to be ready for the gift when it comes. A donor should be able to see a clear vision, a credible plan, meaningful outcomes, a realistic budget, and a team prepared to execute.

Across the organizations we work with that follow the Five Factors™ Framework, we see an average 200% increase in fundraising. That takes effort, and it pays off. I believe this preparation will become more important in the coming years. Leaders need to understand what they are asking people to fund and be able to show what that investment can accomplish.

If you are overwhelmed and need to raise more money, start by protecting time to answer three questions:

  • What are we trying to change over the long term?
  • What will it cost to make that change?
  • What must we put in place to deliver?

Your answers will shape the plan, the priorities, and the fundraising. The mission deserves that work.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why is transactional fundraising holding my nonprofit back?

Transactional fundraising, which takes the form of chasing sponsorships, selling event tickets, and making small appeals, consumes significant time and energy without yielding transformational growth. It keeps your team focused on maintaining the status quo and trapped in a cycle of burnout, rather than pursuing the larger vision and major investments required for substantial impact.

What is the first step to securing larger investments for my organization?

Before asking for more money, you must define what you are building toward. Start by determining your “big, hairy, audacious goal” (BHAG) and creating a solid business plan. This plan must include a realistic budget that shows exactly what it will cost in terms of people and resources to execute that vision, proving to donors that you are ready for their gift.

How do meaningful outcomes differ from standard nonprofit metrics?

Standard metrics usually track activity and reach, such as the number of meals served or beds provided. Meaningful outcomes measure the actual, lasting change your work creates. Instead of just counting people sheltered, an outcome measures how many of those individuals achieved safe, long-term housing years later. Donors want to invest in lasting change, not just temporary activity.